Question
Salaam to all. Shukran for the help, it helps tremendously.
Please explain to us how Naafi’ reads AAL AANA in surah Yunus
Shukran. Was-salaam
Answer
Wa alaikum assalaam wa
rahmatullahi wa barakatuh.
Both
and
read
the word 
, which has
a questioning hamzah as the first letter before a hamzah al-wasl followed by
a 
saakinah, followed
then another
, then an
alif and the last letter a noon, in surah Yunus aayah 51 and 91 with
(transfer) of the
vowel of the second
to the
saakinah preceding
it. This is the normal case for the reading of Warsh, since it is part of
the basic rules of Warsh that we transfer the vowel on a hamzah to the
saakin preceding it. This is a special case for the reading of Qaloon.
There are two ways of
reading this word for all ways of recitation:
1.
With
of
the hamzah al-wasl an alif with a six vowel count lengthening.
2.
With 
of the
hamzah al-wasl between a hamzah and an alif with no lengthening.
In the case of those
that read this word with
(transfer of the
vowel), such as Qaloon and Warsh, there are two ways of reading the way of
:
a.
With the six vowel count lengthening of the alif (changed from hamzah
al-wasl) taking into consideration the original sukoon on the laam.
b.
With just a two vowel count lengthening of the alif, taking into
consideration that the laam is now voweled.
Qaloon then has
three allowed ways of reading this word, two ways with
of
the hamzah wasl an alif, one with a full six vowel count medd, the other
with just two vowel counts, the third way is with
of the hamzah
with no lengthening.
There is a
after
the laam saakinah, and we know from the lessons on Warsh in the tidbit
lesson link
http://www.abouttajweed.com/titbitlessons.htm see lesson two- that
Warsh lengthens
two,
four, or six vowel counts. There is a note in lesson two that some scholars
make an exception to the four and six vowel count
in
this word (), but
since some allow it, it is still permitted to read
with
two, four, or six vowel counts.
If we look at the
phrases 
and
in surah
Yunus 51 and 91 respectfully completely by themselves without stopping on
the word , the
reading of Warsh has seven possible ways of reading
all having
of the vowel on the
hamzah after the lam to the lam.
a.
of
the hamzah wasl alif with a six vowel count lengthening on the alif, and
two, four, or six vowel counts for
(three
ways).
b.
of
the hamzah wasl with two, four, or six vowel counts for
(three
ways).
c.
of the hamzah wasl
alif with only two vowel counts on the alif and only two vowel counts
allowed for
(one way).
‘Afwan. Wa assalaam
alaikum wa rahmatullah.
